Trading Card Games: Trade-In Rates for Card Singles

MTG Card Back.png
PTCG Card Back.png

Magic: the Gathering

Store-Credit rate: 50% Market Value
Cash Rate: 20% Market Value


Store-Credit rate: 40% Market Value
Cash Rate: 10% Market Value

We take Trade-Ins!
Here at Arkham we use market prices determined by TCGPlayer to determine the value of all cards that are brought in.
In order to receive any market value for a card, it's market price must be at or above $1.00.
Any card valued at less than $1.00 is considered "Bulk" trade-in and can only be traded
in for store-credit at a rate of .01¢ per card.

COVID-19 Temporary Change:
As we have switched to credit-only purchases, cash payouts are currently suspended. Only store-credit is being offered for trade-ins.